It wasn't almost dying, it was believing that he had found his little girl in the void. At the end of the episode, the two new detectives (Gilbough and Papania) are looking for the church Russ mentioned. He did his best and failed and so was allowed to die accorsing to whatever he believed in or whatever rules he had set for himself. HBO. The ending was great. in the Carcosa sequence. Naturally, I am intrigued by the characters and really looking forward to watch something along those same lines. He's an intelligent former family man who latched onto these concepts to deal with his grief. I also love Marty's comment to him "For someone who believes reality doesn't matter, you sure spend an awful lot of time fretting about it.". That's not out of character, that's character development. Of all of True Detective season two's storytelling sins, this is the one that has been most thoroughly adjudicated, even by fans of the season. She puts great emphasis on the fact that "he had children of all colors". (Thanks socrates). All those years, trials, and tribulations just for Rust and/or Marty to die at the hands of some crazy fat redneck would’ve been really shitty and in vain. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I was wondering why. I agree, but some people while they loved the season, they were disappointed by the ending. And Rust hasn't always been this way. True Detective review: season one finale – Form and Void Spoiler alert: this review is for US viewers. Have you all found anything like it ? Catch up on True Detective Season 1 and 2 now on HBO. From my own personal experience, I would venture to guess that a large percentage of pessimists wish to be proven wrong about their beliefs. Link to my book below. I’ll take the bittersweet ending NP gave us over my dumb expectations. Also, if you're interested, the last chapter of my book looks at Rust & Marty's behavior through the lens of the coping mechanisms Zapffe describes in "The Last Messiah." More posts from the TrueDetective community, Press J to jump to the feed. It's not like he found Christ and was suddenly preaching the bible. There will be SPOILERS. Comment deleted by user 3 years ago. His ordeal was like going through the crucible, which burned all the cynical, material-focused impurities out of his soul/psyche/spirit/consciousness or whatever you want to call it. Rustin Cohle describes the killer as “meta-psychotic”.After the autopsy, the detectives learn that the victim was drugged, bound, abused, tortured with a knife, strangled and posed outside for the world to see. https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=245&v=5_y5AcBV0x0&feature=emb_logo, https://philosophynow.org/issues/45/The_Last_Messiah, http://sequart.org/magazine/69503/sequart-releases-time-is-a-flat-circle-examining-true-detective-season-one/. Upon recent rewatch there are little lines and behaviors that suggest Rust is partly trying to convince himself that what he’s saying is true. As with every episode prior, "Form and Void" gave fans plenty to ponder, so let's get right to it. In a very real way, Rust is the light of this show, disguising himself in darkness, to reveal truth and bring justice where it’s deserved. my biggest issue with it is that i think Nic gave into his love for the characters and tried to wrap them up as nicely as possible. He's the source of Rust's rants about consciousness being a burden. It might be against the philosophy that he exposes in the begining of the series but I'd also say not at all off-character and that's because of his character arc, the near death was an experience that altered the philosophy he used to cope with the suffering of life, he got a glimpse of the full energy of life just by being ready to lose it. Yeah I sort of thought the same thing about Rust. And that seems to follow Rust's character arc ... that he would be engaged in life's more esoteric mysteries with the same vitality as before - only now with a renewed understand that life is far more precious than what he originally believed. I watched this show on the recommendation of a friend and related intensely to Rust’s character. The life of Wayne Hays (Mahershala Ali) has slowly unfurled non-chronologically over past eight weeks on HBO, using his major unsolved case as a way to explore the power of memory and time in a wholly unexpected way. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Finding a different way to deal with the suffering/ life panic is NOT a happy ending. True Detective season 3's ending brings a great TV story to a close in perfect, emotional fashion. In short, it bares all of the signs of mega-ritual of Satanic Ritual Abuse (… The first season of True Detective, an American anthology crime drama television series created by Nic Pizzolatto, premiered on January 12, 2014, on the premium cable network HBO.The principal cast consisted of Matthew McConaughey, Woody Harrelson, Michelle Monaghan, Michael Potts, and Tory Kittles.The season had eight episodes, and its initial airing concluded on March 9, 2014. And so much to the point a little girl would notice while being chased running in the woods? I am still a pessimist, but I do think that there’s some place where our energy goes now. I fully expected that one of the new detectives, Papania or Gilbough, would turn out to be a deep-cover member of the Tuttle organization. I was hoping that the bad guy wouldn’t turn out to be an incestual retard though. Or is it time is a flat circle and Ill only end up back where I … It made me rethink my views. I guess it depends through which lens you want to view it. True Detective season 1 is a revered piece of television.Coming out in the midst of TV’s Golden Age, it managed to stand apart from the crowd thanks to its A-list cast members, visual flair, and Reddit-baiting mystery.Not since Lost had a series sent people scurrying to the internet in search of answers and theories after each episode. I read a lot of the pessimist and nihilist philosophers Rust quotes in the show, but there's one that really stood out to me: Peter Wessel Zapffe. All I felt was love and that everything was connected. Rust’s renewed optimism is a logical end to his character arc and growth over the series. I'm a robot. -- NP's arrogant dismissal of the plagiarism claims. It was beautiful. I don’t think so at all. The only thing I was disappointed with was the twist I expected that didn't happen. It wasn’t anything religiously described, but it was absolutely fulfilling. Finished season 1 yesterday. And I am disappointed that they didn’t catch the powerful people involved even though they knew who they were. i've never been more tense or excited watching anything as when Rust spins round and shouts "Marty, clear the house". WARNING: Spoilers for the True Detective season 3 finale. I think, maybe, what OP meant was Rust’s belief of an afterlife. I hear his family had been there for a long time. It seemed out of character for a man who spent a majority of his life not only disbelieving in such notions but seemingly actively studying various philosophies. 'True Detective' Season 1, Episode 4 Recap: Every Clue Revealed By Zoë Triska In this week's episode, "Who Goes There," Rust and Marty begin … By: Jay Dyer “All the most powerful ideas in history go back to archetypes. So frustrating. Rejoice, for life doesn't have to end (or something like that). I do agree with OP that it seems rash, but not entirely unrealistic. Report Save. We use cookies on our websites for a number of purposes, including analytics and performance, functionality and advertising. In a series where every detail matters, I have never seen the significance of this information. Have you all found anything like it ? It's maybe 2.5 pages long and really easily accessible don't need to be an academic to understand it). -- Plagiarised final scene. I'd say it says more about you that you believe it is character assassination. Especially considering the amount of reading he's done and he probably has read about near death experiences as well. The first season of True Detective captivated the viewing public this year, topped only by Breaking Bad in attention and critical praise. I feel like it was too neat to be realistic. http://sequart.org/magazine/69503/sequart-releases-time-is-a-flat-circle-examining-true-detective-season-one/. A True Detective true believer might also argue that the show’s big, brave message is that men do terrible things to women—whether it’s Marty or whether it’s Errol. The man tells them it no longer exists, and gives them detailed directions back to the highway. So much of the shows symbolism is tied up in that, from the imagery of rural Louisiana, to the heart/soul metaphor of Rust and Cohle, to Rust's ability to obtain confessions through a nearly religious absolution. Or something. I interpreted it to illustrate that even with a rational mind, even pessimistically intelligent people can be "shook" by something that proves that the whole universe is bigger than themselves. The whole story is about him cutting himself off from God - and not the God of the Yellow King that is simply a veil to obscure immorality and greed, but the God of the backwoods church-tent revival. As time has worn on, that legacy has only become greater. Four years ago I got a bad infection from a surgery and was on ECMO (Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation. Life is suffering. Ok, so I just watched True Detective, (season 1 only) and I think it is as good as they said. Now that the first season of True Detective is officially over, it's time to over-analyze the finale. I just finished watching True Detective season 1 & absolutely loved it. Second one is “True Detective Season 1 Analysis of the Occult Artwork”, written by a fan, and is exactly what the title says. People were speculating it would be green noise cancelling headphones. Louisiana True Detectives Rust and Marty finally got to the bottom of a very disturbing, 17-year-old mystery Sunday night -- but did the HBO series' season-ender give you the resolution you craved? The idea of this cult being a true evil in the world, and yet, at the same time, seeming TRUE, that their followers ARE rewarded and that their beliefs may actually hold weight, is pretty ominous. level 1. I looked at it like Rust was convinced he knew how it all worked, it was just supposed to suck, then he gets a glimpse at a reality he doesn't understand, and now he knows he knows nothing. See my analysis of True Detective Season 1 here. Love - the love for his daughter, and even beyond that to the complete dissolution of the ego - is a more true and fulfilling approach to all of life. You just cannot have the single most transformational moment for your central character happen offscreen. Staring into what you perceive as absolute truth isn’t enjoyable for those of us touched by tragedy and an over abundance of awareness. Season 1's eight episodes were lauded by critics, earning an 87% on Rotten Tomatoes with a 100% Audience Score. After I rewatched the finale about 30 times I settled on this-Rust had the death experience and felt the true love of his daughter. I don’t know why they didn’t make it that instead. Etc, etc. This is particularly true of religious ideas, but the central concepts of science, philosophy, and ethics are no exception to this rule. Blogs and Reddit have been flooded since the Season Three finale on Sunday with theories about the ending. No one will debate that Rust Cohle singlehandedly relaunched his career. By: Jay Dyer. In 2014, HBO released the first season of the anthology crime drama series True Detective, directed by Cary Joji Fukunaga of No Time to Die and starring Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson as detectives Rust Cohle and Marty Hart, respectively. He has a reason now to believe that life actually means something and that there's some kind of afterlife to look forward to. He had character development. Not sure who didn't like it? My problem with Nic's wrap up was that both Marty and Rust survived. I think that opened his heart and it was new for him. The True Detective community, however, wouldn't let things end so easily. It’s a form of life support) due to lung failure. We don’t see where Rust goes from there and speculating kind of ruins the whole point. It obviously slipped into my subconscious. There's an English language version of "The Last Messiah" available to read for free here: https://philosophynow.org/issues/45/The_Last_Messiah . There is a scene in one of the last couple of episodes where Marty and Rust interview an elderly black woman who used to work for the patriarch of the Tuttles. Got away with it for decades. Of course, Matthew McConaughey's performance was superb. I think he was a schizo genius. A lot of people seem to be disappointed by the ending of season 1. Who the hell gets paint on both of their ears and only their ears specifically? Not at all, NP said he was always writing towards that ending. He was very good at what he did. Brilliant, weird noir series True Detective had its season finale last night, and the ending probably wasn’t what most viewers expected. The trauma showed him that a strictly rational philosophical analysis of the world is not complete or balanced. It usually denotes a place or a city and usually is related to The King in Yellow - though what exactly he is may vary from story to story. I liked it, maybe some edgy atheists didn't like it. ... Just remember when Rust was in his hospital bed at the end - they spoke about how they wern't going to get them all. A shaman is sometimes called a wounded healer. They stop to ask a man on a lawnmower for directions. ", New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the TrueDetective community, Press J to jump to the feed. He goes into Carcosa alone and is willing to sacrifice himself to save future children and get justice for the children who have already died. But part of what makes him such a compelling character has nothing to do with McCounaughey's performance. And after his NDE, its no coincidence he looks up at the stars and smiles. for Rust, of all people, to come through decades of torment with a positive, chipper attitude on life felt a bit dishonest, pretty much all of his life's worth had disappeared with the solving of the case and when you think about it, Rust's life is probably only gonna get worse. But upon a rewatch years later and more reflection, it was a good ending to the season. My friend and I sought out and visited as many filming locations as we could -- all over the area. [This is a review for True Detective season 1, episode 8. There's just different ways of dealing with that suffering. ... 'True Detective' Season 1, Episode 7 Recap: 'After You've Gone' Anyone else find it character assassination for Rust to just get hope from a near-death experience? -- the awful 70s-style DRAMATIC MUSIC!!! See my analysis of True Detective Season 2 here. It wasn't your average season finale. The series finale likely left more questions than answers for the HBO drama’s obsessive fans It's so out of character for him to give that much meaning to tripping balls on nearly dying. True Detective season one never fully explains this strange, cosmic occurrence, nor many of the other unexplained mysteries, but the end result is something troubling and chilling. I, for one, did happen to like it. Carcosa is a term found in many works of fiction such as those written by Ambrose Bierce and Robert W. Chambers, who is probably mostly associated with the name. Even if you relate to the philosophy, it should be obvious that a lot of the time, he's spouting that stuff to convince himself as much as others. While the Internet is rife with theories and analysis, few have succeeded in plumbing the depths of the story in its proper fullness. 14. Sure he did his best to survive as a detective and sure he drank a lot as a bar tender, but he would never outright kill himself no matter how much he wanted to die. The first season of True Detective, an American anthology crime drama television series created by Nic Pizzolatto, premiered on January 12, 2014, on the premium cable network HBO.The principal cast consisted of Matthew McConaughey, Woody Harrelson, Michelle Monaghan, Michael Potts, and Tory Kittles.The season had eight episodes, and its initial airing concluded on March 9, 2014. I’m a huge pessimist (went to catholic school since kindergarten and thought it was all bs). At first I was slightly disappointed, because my expectation was that Rust would die. I’ve come to look at Rust’s change of heart coming down to him giving in to the allure and relief of hope. ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts. Naturally, I am intrigued by the characters and really looking forward to watch something along those same lines.